April 24, 2012
Court rejects NYC rent-control challenge
WASHINGTON (UPI) -- The U.S. Supreme Court Monday left in place a lower-court ruling that said New York's rent-control law was not an unconstitutional "taking" of property.
The "takings clause" of the Constitution bans government appropriation of property without just compensation. The 14th Amendment makes that and other rights applicable not only to the federal government but to state and local governments.
James and Jeanne Harmon, who own and live in a small brownstone in Manhattan, filed suit complaining that the city's Rent Stabilization Law forced them to allow reduced rent for three tenants, and their designated successors, for 90 years without regard to need. The Harmons said the rents were set by law at 59 percent below market.
A federal judge dismissed the complaint and a federal appeals court in New York agreed. In a summary order, the appeals court said, "In some instances, government regulation of private property may be 'so onerous that its effect is tantamount to a direct appropriation or ouster -- and that such regulatory takings may be compensable under the Fifth Amendment,'" citing U.S. Supreme Court precedent.
"Here, there is no dispute that the RSL was enacted and became applicable to the Harmons' property many years before they took ownership of it [in 2005]," the appeals court order said. "Thus, the Harmons' argument that the RSL impairs their lease agreements with rent-stabilized tenants is without merit."
The U.S. Supreme Court rejected the case without comment. The rejection sets no precedent.
louis vuitton handbags ugg shoes michael kors handbags uggs outlet insanity workout christian louboutin outlet fitflops outlet true religion jeans red bottom heels michael kors outlet red bottom shoes louis vuitton outlet canada goose jackets oakley sunglasses cheap louis vuitton ferragamo black friday 2014 michael kors handbags louboutin shoes true religion cheap nfl jerseys louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton handbags polo ralph lauren outlet michael kors outlet online coach outlet tory burch outlet coach bags louis vuitton outlet stores coach factory outlet michael kors sale polo ralph lauren ghd hair strighteners ugg boots sale michael kors handbags coach factory outlet louis vuitton christian louboutin sale black friday 2014 louis vuitton louis vuitton outlet cheap jerseys north face outlet burberry uk coach cyber monday 2014 coach outlet tory burch outlet christian louboutin shoes christian louboutin coach factory outlet louis vuitton outlet online louis vuitton outlet cheap nfl jerseys louis vuitton outlet stores louis vuitton outlet online gucci outlet coach outlet michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet stores coach factory outlet givenchy cheap jordans prada outlet abercrombie louis vuitton online stores coach outlet lululemon fendi outlet michael kors outlet online coach factory outlet michael kors outlet coach factory outlet coach outlet hollister clothing coach outlet michael kors outlet jordan shoes christian louboutin shoes north face jackets celine outlet polo ralph lauren outlet louis vuitton outlet chi flat iron coach bags north face jackets louis vuitton louis vuitton coach outlet bottega veneta outlet polo ralph lauren outlet ugg outlet versace outlet coach factory outlet moncler jacket alexander wang oakley sunglasses coach bags coach outlet coach cyber monday 2014 ugg outlet juicy couture jimmy choo outlet north face outlet louis vuitton outlet online dolce gabbana kate spade outlet canada goose cyber monday 2014 tory burch outlet mont blanc pens michael kors outlet mont blanc pen coach factory outlet christian louboutin outlet cheap jerseys ugg boots dior handbags hermes birkin louis vuitton cheap uggs michael kors outlet michael kors handbags outlet coach outlet store online michael kors outlet online north face outlet cheap uggs christian louboutin outlet coach handbags louis vuitton handbags christian louboutin outlet louis vuitton michael kors handbags louis vuitton outlet stores coach factory outlet louis vuitton outlet stores coach factory outlet hogan shoes ralph lauren outlet louis vuitton outlet hollister clothing p90x workouts louis vuitton belstaff jacket cheap louis vuitton cheap jerseys coach bags coach factory outlet rayban sunglasses christian louboutin outlet fitflop shoes cheap louis vuitton black friday 2014 coach factory outlet louis vuitton outlet burberry outlet ugg boots burberry handbags the north face outlet coach outlet louis vuitton factory outlet north face jackets abercrombie fitch hermes belts cheap nfl jerseys cheap ugg boots ugg outlet louis vuitton handbags michael kors outlet online louis vuitton coach outlet michael kors outlet coach outlet coach factory outlet michael kors outlet celine outlet north face coach outlet abercrombie outlet abercrombie & fitch michael kors outlet online ralph lauren outlet nike shoes coach outlet louis vuitton outlet michael kors outlet coach outlet cheap uggs michael kors outlet online louis vuitton outlet mulberry christian louboutin outlet timberland boots polo ralph lauren outlet louis vuitton outlet online supra shoes cheap uggs canada goose cyber monday 2014 rayban outlet coach cyber monday 2014 cheap jerseys cheap jerseys louis vuitton outlet burberry outlet michael kors outlet ralph lauren outlet burberry bags moncler outlet coach factory outlet coach handbags ugg boots sale ugg australia louis vuitton coach black friday 2014 louis vuitton outlet online coach outlet north face jackets moncler jackets coach factory outlet online marc jacobs christian louboutin outlet louis vuitton outlet cheap uggs coach factory outlet polo ralph lauren outlet the north face outlet toms shoes fitflop cheap louis vuitton chanel outlet guess outlet ugg boots marc jacobs north face outlet toms shoes michael kors outlet sale coach factory outlet ugg australia canada goose black friday 2014